Art and design






Life and style








US news

World news

The Melody by Jim Crace review – a story with real bite

Jim Crace: ‘doesn’t let us develop a simple picture of where or when this is happening’
Jim Crace: ‘doesn’t let us develop a simple picture of where or when this is happening’. Photograph: David Levenson/Getty Images

“I also ought to thank the people of...” That’s how the acknowledgments to Jim Crace’s new novel end, mid-sentence at the foot of the page, as if in error. Although this is the kind of game Crace has played ever since his 1986 debut, Continent, which fabricated an epigraph from “the Histories of Pycletius”, no one imagined he was joking when he noted in his acknowledgments to his last novel, 2013’s Booker-shortlisted Harvest, that he had “enjoyed a fortunate career in books and publishing” – an ominously solemn observation that sounded (as interviews confirmed) a lot like goodbye.

Well, maybe Crace played us yet again, because here he is once more, on typically strange, slippery form. It starts when the concert singer Alfred Busi is attacked by a mysterious nocturnal scavenger rummaging in the larder of the seaside villa that has been his home for seven decades. Nursing a nasty bite to his hand, as well as the pungent memory of his assailant’s potato-like odour, he turns for help – in the absence of his late wife – to his sister-in-law, Terina, who once gave him an evening to remember and still inspires chaste fantasy. He’s less keen to talk to his nephew, a timber tycoon whose plan to gentrify the area finds a handy catalyst in the ensuing newspaper gossip about the scary beast-like hominids lurking in the nearby woodland.

The Melody’s dust jacket promises high drama, with a strapline (lifted from the text) about “a rumour... as true as it was brutal”. Really Busi’s late-night encounter heralds a delicate meditation on grief, creativity and – less predictably – poverty, as his story dovetails with the fate of the shadowy locals of “the bosk”, feared, othered and ultimately wiped out for the sake of greed.

The first-person narrator, taking his sweet time to reveal himself, records Busi’s thoughts in retrospect, addressing us like we’re part of the locale, recalling events in our collective memory. As ever, Crace doesn’t let us develop a simple picture of where or when this is happening. It isn’t just that he withholds detail; his tricky use of tense and mood makes temporal uncertainty intrinsic. At one point Busi has a dream (which, we’re told, “he would be retelling” in “less than an hour”) about concert-goers “elated by the music they had heard” at one of his future performances – “if, indeed, the famous singer had shown up”.

For all that this sort of thing keeps you on your toes, The Melody sometimes threatens to become (almost literally) a shaggy dog story, with the novel’s central conflict between profit and justice settled offstage rather than in the hinted-at grandstand finish. Yet the book retains a lingering power – not least in Crace’s gentle reminder that, although the personal may well be political, it’s often easier to pretend otherwise.

The Melody by Jim Crace is published by Picador (£16.99). To order a copy for £12.99 go to or call 0330 333 6846. Free UK p&p over £10, online orders only. Phone orders min p&p of £1.99

This article titled "The Melody by Jim Crace review – a story with real bite" was written by Anthony Cummins, for The Observer on Tuesday 13 February 2018 08.00am


Nefertiti’s Face by Joyce Tyldesley review – the creation of an Ancient Egyptian icon

Even with her blinded left eye, Nefertiti has come to epitomise female perfection. Uncannily… Read more

Top 10 books about cheating

Why do we keep coming back to the adultery novel? What is it about infidelity that bears retelling… Read more

Skin in the Game by Nassim Nicholas Taleb review – how risk should be shared

Skin in the Game is Nassim Nicholas Taleb’s fifth book. He presents it sometimes as part of a… Read more

George Washington's hair found tucked in old book in New York library

A researcher at the Schaffer Library in New York has discovered what is believed to be a lock of… Read more

Awards for women, writers of colour, small presses – why are there so many books prizes?

How many literary prizes are there in the UK today? To Wikipedia’s tally of around 70, I can… Read more

Tomorrow by Elisabeth Russell Taylor review – an early 90s gem

Taylor’s reissued 1991 novel feels as though it could date from much earlier in the century, such… Read more

The many tongues of Lost in Books, the only bookstore in Fairfield

Walking into Lost in Books is a little like walking into a daydream. Models of hot air balloons… Read more

Lionel Shriver says 'politically correct censorship' is damaging fiction

Lionel Shriver, the author of We Need To Talk About Kevin, has warned that “politically correct… Read more

Only half of pre-school children being read to daily, UK study finds

The proportion of toddlers being read to every day has dropped by a fifth over the last five years,… Read more

Fire Sermon by Jamie Quatro review – debut novel from a short-story writer

After millennia joined at the hip, art and faith largely parted ways, at least in terms of art as… Read more