Art and design

Books

Culture

Environment

Fashion

Film

Life and style

Money

Music

Politics

Science

Technology

Travel

Television

US news

World news

New airplane biofuels plan would 'destroy rainforests', warn campaigners

An aircraft flies over Frankfurt, leaving contrails above the cloud
The ‘green jet fuel’ plan would ramp up the use of aviation biofuels to 5m tonnes a year by 2025. Photograph: Michael Probst/AP

A new plan to accelerate production of biofuels for passenger planes has drawn stinging criticism from environmentalists who argue that most of the world’s rainforests might have to be cleared to produce the necessary crops.

Aviation is one of the fastest growing sources of greenhouse gas emissions, with an 8% leap reported in Europe last year and a global fourfold increase in CO2 pollution expected by 2050.

To rein this back, the industry has promised carbon neutral growth by 2020 – to be met by biofuels, if a blueprint is approved at an International Civil Aviation Organisation (Icao) conference in Mexico City tomorrow.

The “green jet fuel” plan would ramp up the use of aviation biofuels to 5m tonnes a year by 2025, and 285m tonnes by 2050 – enough to cover half of overall demand for international aviation fuel.

But this is also three times more biofuels than the world currently produces, and advanced biofuels are still at too early a stage of development to make up the difference.

Environmentalists say that the most credible alternative fuel source would be hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO), even though this would probably trigger a boom in palm oil plantations and a corresponding spike in deforestation.

Klaus Schenk of Rainforest Rescue said: “Citizens around the world are very concerned about burning palm oil in planes. The vast use of palm oil for aviation biofuels would destroy the world’s rainforests, the basis of life for local people and the habitats of endangered species such as orangutans. We urge Icao to scrap its misguided biofuels plan.”

It is impossible to quantify the precise extent of deforestation that the proposal could cause, but based on the Malaysian Palm Oil Council’s crude palm oil yields and Total conversion figures, Biofuelwatch estimate that 82.3m hectares of land (316,603 sq miles) would be needed to meet the target, if it were sourced from palm oil alone. That is more than three times the size of the UK.

Carlos Calvo Ambel, a spokesman for Transport and Environment, said: “Most biofuels are worse for the climate than jet fuel. Quality should always go before quantity. Establishing a goal even before the rules are set out is putting the cart before the horse. The European experience has been that biofuels targets sucked in palm oil exports whose emissions were far greater than those of fossil fuels.”

T&E, Oxfam and Friends of the Earth are among nearly 100 environmental groups protesting the proposal, while 181,000 people have signed a petition calling for the initiative to be scrapped.

Inside the conference hall, several states are also opposing the biofuels pitch which, if passed, is expected to go on to an Icao assembly for formal adoption within two years.

Brazil and Indonesia strongly support the plan but China has questioned its feasibility, the EU wants more robust sustainability criteria, and the US says it will not support globally coordinated emissions reductions targets.

An industry proposal to limit the biofuels target to 2025 is one possible compromise, but others may emerge before the plan is put to a vote.

Almuth Ernsting, a spokeswoman for Biofuelwatch, said the current proposed target was “so huge that it would be unlikely to be fulfilled – but you could still have massive negative impacts from much smaller uses of palm oil”.

Within four years of the EU setting a binding target to source 10% of its transport fuel from renewable sources in 2009, studies show that European investors had bought 6m hectares of land for biofuels production in sub-Saharan Africa.

The EU took very little of its biofuel feedstock from Africa in the end, but the use of palm oil from elsewhere for biodiesel had soared 500% by 2014, according to industry trade figures.

This article titled "New airplane biofuels plan would 'destroy rainforests', warn campaigners" was written by Arthur Neslen, for theguardian.com on Thursday 12 October 2017 05.17pm

Environment

Country diary: stalking red deer on the fringes of the city

Running south from the old Barbrook reservoir, I found myself struggling against the strong… Read more

Kea or Kākāriki? Bird of the Year contest gets New Zealand in a flap

First there was the “Jacinda effect” and a government to cobble together. Then came the mania for… Read more

New Zealand Bird of the Year leaderboard: check the pecking order

Read more

Insectageddon, fatal pollution and 2017 Wildlife Photographer winners – green news roundup

Environment news Warning of ‘ecological Armageddon’ after dramatic plunge in insect numbers ‘The… Read more

A giant insect ecosystem is collapsing due to humans. It's a catastrophe

Thirty-five years ago an American biologist Terry Erwin conducted an experiment to count insect… Read more

Is Congress about to wreck America's natural treasures?

One-hundred-eleven years and a few months ago, Theodore Roosevelt signed the landmark law that… Read more

National energy guarantee is ‘innovative’, says Bloomberg analysis

The Turnbull government’s proposed national energy guarantee has been given enthusiastic support by… Read more

Country diary: the woodland is intoxicating at this time of year

Without doubt, 200 years ago our walk would have made a slow start. We would have been watching… Read more

UK may consider electric vehicle subsidy to increase cycling

The UK government could potentially consider providing subsidies for electric bicycles and electric… Read more

High court proves we have free speech against environmental wreckers | Bob Brown

The high court has drawn a line in the sand against laws which burden the right of Australians to… Read more