Art and design






Life and style








US news

World news

Proof that sustainable meat and dairy farming can work | Letters

Cow and calf
Cow and calf. ‘We have greatly extended the period of time the calves remain with their mothers, from 24 hours to between five and six months,’ writes David Finlay. Photograph: Tim Scrivener/Alamy

I had just got back into the house from milking the cows when I read the discussion (Letters, 7 October) on George Monbiot’s latest contribution to the debate about the future of our food production system. While George is a fundamentalist, I must confess I agree with much of what he says! The problem is that, as an extremist fundamentalist, he just goes too far. Here on our rented family farm of 100 dairy cows with some beef and sheep, we are in the first year of a three-year, final-stage experiment to challenge the idea that treating our animals, land, environment and the people who work and live here with respect is somehow incompatible with financial viability and our industry’s ability to provide adequate amounts of affordable food, and is therefore unsustainable.

This is the final part of a much longer-term experiment, incorporating agroecology, agroforestry and calf-with-cow dairying along with appropriate technologies that allow us to achieve these public benefit outcomes. On paper this could work. In practice it hasn’t been easy. But there are glimmers of daylight. We are on the final stretch and many of our targets have been met: substantial (90%-plus) cuts in the use of antibiotics, anthelmintics, vaccines, soluble fertiliser and pesticides (and diffuse pollution) without compromising productivity or animal health; and substantial increases in biodiversity and reductions in staff working hours.

We have greatly extended the period of time the calves remain with their mothers, from 24 hours to between five and six months. This is the final challenge, but when you see something you know is right, it’s about finding ways to make it work, not giving up. So please, don’t bundle all farmers into the same pigeonhole, George. The consensus – outside of vested interests – is that there is room for meat and dairy in sustainable diets. We just have to be a good bit more selective.
David Finlay
Castle Douglas, Galloway

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit

This article titled "Proof that sustainable meat and dairy farming can work" was written by Letters, for The Guardian on Thursday 12 October 2017 05.35pm


The US is penny wise and pound foolish on the climate | John Abraham

The United States is great in many respects. But we certainly aren’t perfect; we’ve made some… Read more

Northern Territory to decide about fracking ban only after inquiry's final report

The Northern Territory government will wait until next year to make a decision on lifting its… Read more

Country diary: snow changes everything the other side of the doorstep

Black-white-black-white: the bull watches the bird through the snow. This is the first flurry for… Read more

Tesco faces legal threat over marketing its food with' fake farm' names

Major UK supermarkets including Tesco, Aldi, Asda and Lidl are being urged to stop using… Read more

EU announces €9bn in funding for climate action

The European commission has announced funding of €9bn (£8bn) for action on climate change, one of a… Read more

Calls for greater fossil fuel divestment at anniversary of Paris climate deal

The Paris agreement on climate change, ratified by world governments a year ago, has failed to… Read more

English rivers polluted by powerful insecticides, first tests reveal

Rivers in England are contaminated with powerful insecticides, new testing has revealed, increasing… Read more

Weatherwatch: the 'halcyon days' of December hark back to the kingfisher

The ancients called them the “halcyon days” – a period of fine, settled weather, lasting roughly… Read more

Golden eagles released in Scotland with hope they will fly south

Conservationists hope golden eagles will start reappearing over northern England and the Lake… Read more

Quarter of Christmas jumpers were worn once and discarded last year

One in four Christmas jumpers bought last year was thrown away or is unlikely to be worn again,… Read more