Art and design

Books

Culture

Environment

Fashion

Film

Life and style

Money

Music

Politics

Science

Technology

Travel

Television

US news

World news

Trust’s critics can’t see the wood for the trees | Letters

Walkers stroll through wintry woodlands in Nottinghamshire
Walkers stroll through wintry woodlands in Nottinghamshire. Photograph: Alamy Stock Photo

The response in your letters section to the northern forest raised some useful points (Development for the north? Let them eat wood, 9 January). However, drawing parallels between the Woodland Trust’s native woodland policy and xenophobia demonstrates ignorance of the ecology and the conservation of semi-natural woodlands. Britain’s native woodlands are so diverse because of the association and dependency of species that have co-evolved over several thousand years. 

The accusation that we create “plantations of birch and rowan and field maple, producing scrub rather than woodland” couldn’t be further from the truth (and, by the way, scrub habitat has huge conservation value). We use local tree and shrub species to create diverse, functioning and resilient habitats for biodiversity and local communities.

While other organisations have an important role in promoting non-native species for productive forests, our aim has been to champion and protect what’s left of our precious ancient woodland and create new native woodlands where the opportunity arises. Readers should be reassured, all our native tree species (with the exception of some rare Sorbus species) are actually quite “multicultural” and are found throughout many other parts of Europe.
Dr James Paterson
Conservation adviser, Woodland Trust

• I fear that your correspondent Derek Goldrei is being overoptimistic. Decades before the northern forest is harvested for sleepers or anything else, millions of leaves will have rained down, ensuring that the polluting, underpowered bi-mode and diesel trains (foisted on us by the Department for Transport’s abandonment of electrification) will for years to come be slipping and sliding up the gradients of the Pennines every autumn.
Paul Birchall
Derby

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters

This article titled "Trust’s critics can’t see the wood for the trees" was written by Letters, for The Guardian on Thursday 11 January 2018 07.14pm

Environment

Specieswatch: greater tussock-sedge – safe haven and playground

As a child living deep in the country, the greater tussock sedge, Carex paniculata, provided me… Read more

Japan to replace whaling mother ship in sign hunts will go on

Japan is to defy Australia and other nations with plans to replace its whaling fleet’s ageing… Read more

New fountains and bottle-refill points to tackle London's plastic waste

A new network of drinking fountains and bottle-refill points is set to be rolled out across London… Read more

Murky world of 'science' journals a new frontier for climate deniers | Graham Readfearn

There’s a new scientific journal you might not have heard of called the International Journal of… Read more

New global registry of invasive species is 'milestone' in protecting biodiversity

A world registry of invasive species has been launched amid concerns that governments are not doing… Read more

Gas field earthquakes put Netherlands’ biggest firms on extraction notice

Two hundred of the Netherlands’ biggest companies have been told by their government to stop… Read more

Trump's tariffs on panels will cost US solar industry thousands of jobs

Donald Trump’s decision to impose a tariff on imported solar panels will cost the US solar industry… Read more

'Blended' finance is key to achieving global sustainability goals, says report

Tackling climate change and achieving the world’s sustainable development goals will require… Read more

Satellite Eye on Earth: November and December 2017 - in pictures

Dust blowing out of the Copper River valley on Alaska’s south coast. The dust plume was likely… Read more

Renewed calls for UK to tackle toxic air ahead of high court hearing

The government is coming under renewed pressure to introduce a new Clean Air Act to tackle the UK’s… Read more