Art and design






Life and style








US news

World news

RPI no longer fit for deciding rail fare rises | Letters

Man buying rail tickets
‘The annual rises in rail fares should be decoupled from the retail prices index,’ writes Hetan Shah. Photograph: Lauren Hurley/PA

The shadow transport secretary, Andy McDonald, is on the right tracks. The annual rises in rail fares should be decoupled from the retail prices index (RPI), as he argued in his Guardian article (This hefty train fare rise is yet another Tory betrayal of passengers,, 5 December).

The Royal Statistical Society (RSS) has long believed that the RPI should be declared redundant for such uprating purposes. Significantly, our view is shared by both the national statistician and the chair of the UK Statistics Authority, who told MPs, only last month, that he “deprecates” RPI being used in this way.

The RPI was a good measure of inflation for many years but developed various technical problems; legal and other constraints prevented them from being solved. This situation led to its loss of “national statistic” status as far back as 2013.

In these circumstances, it is indefensible that RPI is still used to set people’s rail fares and many of their other outgoings – from air passenger duty to interest on student loans. It is especially unjustifiable as the government uses the consumer prices index (CPI), which normally gives a lower estimate of inflation, when uprating many people’s incomes through state benefits or public sector pensions.

People’s incomes and outgoings should both be linked to a single index which commands “national statistic” status and is credible for uprating purposes. The CPI, while imperfect, meets these key criteria. The household costs index (HCI), currently being developed, may well do so in the future. Alas, the RPI now fails on each count. For uprating purposes, it is surely now reaching the end of the line.
Hetan Shah
Executive director, Royal Statistical Society

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit

This article titled "RPI no longer fit for deciding rail fare rises" was written by Letters, for The Guardian on Wednesday 6 December 2017 06.54pm


When it comes to estate agents, the future could be purple

Plot the share price of Purple Bricks against Countrywide over the past few years and it tells you… Read more

Let’s move to Finnieston, Glasgow: ‘You’ll struggle to find a lampshade in the modish new nitespots’

What’s going for it? Bare lightbulbs. Yes, yes, I know they’re very fashionable right now, thank… Read more

Where to move for wellbeing

I’d like to be well, wouldn’t you? Well, well-er. I’m OK. Midlife dampens expectations, and I’m… Read more

Ground rent: can landlords really demand six years’ payments in one hit?

I read with interest about landlords being able to claim six years’ worth of ground rent providing… Read more

Boohoo says its ‘sale’ will end in minutes – why is it back in a couple of hours?

On Monday night I saw that the Boohoo fashion website was having a fantastic sale – “20% off… Read more

Ryanair: passengers fight for expenses if flights are delayed

When Linda Fisher booked a three-day break in Berlin to visit her boyfriend last August, Ryanair… Read more

Dyson V8: why is the pricing an Absolute farce?

I wanted to buy a Dyson V8 Absolute vacuum cleaner, which appeared to drop in price around Black… Read more

How to make a big career change

Sometimes the hardest part is getting everyone else on board with the idea that you want something… Read more

How best to leave the world of work behind | Letters

Andy Beckett’s long read was elucidating and possibly prescient (Post-work: is the job finished?,… Read more

Milton Keynes: UK capital of ‘right-to-buy-to-let’

The floor in Elina Apse’s house on the Netherfield council estate in Milton Keynes is so cold that… Read more