Art and design






Life and style








US news

World news

The age of the benevolent capitalist is gone | Letters

Bill Gates speaks at Gates Foundation Goalkeepers event in New York.
Bill Gates speaks at Gates Foundation Goalkeepers event in New York. Photograph: Elizabeth Shafiroff/Reuters

My admirable and turbulent priest Giles Fraser (Loose canon, 6 October) concludes that “capitalism is not magic, but exploitative to its core”, as is its principle that “I only get extremely rich if you get a little bit richer too”. Max Weber got it dead right for certain eras in the past, when Calvinistic merchants made money to give it to others, often most of it, frequently living frugally as circumstances permitted to do so (the Protestant work ethic). As a Calvinist country, Scotland was full of such people, for example the Cowans of Penicuik, 19th-century paper manufacturers, or the Coats and Clarks, thread magnates, or Peter Brough of Paisley, whose charitable funds have assisted generations over centuries. England had its Cadburys and Lord Leverhulme, with similar outcomes. They were capitalists too, but they carried it out for others. It’s still possible to do that, if capitalists want. Unfortunately, it seems that few of them have kindred motivations today, although Bill Gates does pretty well.
Professor Sam McKinstry
Gartcosh, Lanarkshire

• Join the debate – email

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit

This article titled "The age of the benevolent capitalist is gone" was written by Letters, for The Guardian on Tuesday 10 October 2017 05.44pm


Autumn budget 2017: a sneak peek inside the chancellor’s red box …

Don’t expect much in the way of fireworks when the chancellor reveals his second budget on… Read more

Stamp duty cut for first-time buyers will push up prices, warns OBR

One of the main measures of the chancellor’s battle to help young buyers into the housing market… Read more

Is Alexa to blame for a costly doll’s house being sent to me by mistake?

I received a Melissa and Doug Victorian Doll’s House – original price £120, now reduced to £89 –… Read more

Soas is bottom of the class when it came to my £340 refund

After attending an open day in mid-September I signed up for a 10-week Chinese evening class at the… Read more

Insurers fear tax rise in 'raid on the responsible'

The government is being urged to avoid “penalising” families and businesses with another hike in… Read more

How much …? The rise of dynamic and personalised pricing

You wait 24 hours to book that flight, only to find it’s gone up by £100. You wait until Black… Read more

Is paying to attend a birthday party now normal?

Every week a Guardian Money reader submits a question, and it’s up to you to help him or her out –… Read more

Should the proceeds of a property sale be used to pay for care home care?

Q My parents-in-law live in a town about 50 minutes away from my husband and I. My father-in-law… Read more

Buying cut-price designer shoes from hmomastery has proved a costly mistake

I ordered two pairs of Opening Ceremony Cici Classic shoes from, which sells… Read more

Axa won’t pay out after my brother’s death meant I had to cancel a trip

My fiance and I booked a holiday in the US for my 40th birthday. I flew out a week earlier on work… Read more