Art and design






Life and style








US news

World news

Regulator sorry for not capping UK consumers' energy bills sooner

Household electricity meter
Dermot Nolan told the select committee the fall in the percentage of people on poor-value tariffs had not been steep enough. Photograph: Alamy

The head of the UK energy regulator has said he will not receive his bonus, as he came under pressure from MPs who accused him of being a passive bystander and failing to prevent millions of customers from paying over the odds.

Dermot Nolan said he would not get his £15,000 bonus this year as he admitted he had not acted quickly enough to help households get off the most expensive tariffs or impose price protections for them.

The chief executive of Ofgem apologised to vulnerable customers for not capping their bills earlier. He also said the decline in the percentage of people on poor-value default tariffs had not been as dramatic as he hoped.

Rachel Reeves, the chair of the business, energy and industrial strategy select committee, said: “It’s not about what you hoped for, you’re the regulator for the energy companies. My children hope for lots of things from Father Christmas; they can hope, they don’t have much impact on what Father Christmas delivers in their stockings.

“But yours isn’t about hope; you are the regulator, you are the person who is delivering or supposed to be delivering on this. The whole language you use is like a bystander, rather than an active participant in the market.”

Peter Kyle, the Labour MP for Hove, said: “Your testimony sounds so incredibly passive. Do you ever roll your sleeves up and really get stuck in? I don’t see any evidence of that.”

Nolan replied: “I apologise if I seem passive, I honestly do not feel passive … I wish we had moved earlier in putting price caps in.”

Reeves asked how he could justify Ofgem staff being awarded nearly £1m in bonuses this year when Nolan had admitted the regulator could have done more and some vulnerable customers were paying too much.

He said it was justified for other staff because a large proportion of Ofgem’s work was not in the retail sector that supplies households, but for himself, he accepted her point and would not receive his bonus.

The decision was made by the regulator’s remuneration committee. Nolan received a £15,000 bonus in 2015-16 and 2016-17 on top of his £190,000 salary.

On the energy price cap Theresa May has promised, he said legislation would need to be given royal assent before the parliamentary recess in July if the protection were to come into effect by Christmas 2018.

He also admitted he thought it was possible some tariffs would go up under the cap on standard variable tariffs and switches between suppliers may fall. “I cannot guarantee that some prices will not rise,” he said.

Nolan said he expected the gap between the cheapest and most expensive tariffs on the market to fall from the £200-£300 found by the competition watchdog in 2016 to about £50-£100 by 2023. That is the latest date the cap can be extended to, under the draft legislation.

He also made it clear that while he was committed to implementing a cap, he was not a fan of them. “I remain of the view that effective competition in the long run is better than a regulated market,” Nolan told the committee.

Official figures revealed on Thursday that a record 5.5 million people switched energy supplier in 2017, up 15% on the year before. Energy UK, the lobby group that represents the big six and other suppliers, hailed the numbers as evidence competition in the market was working.

• Follow Guardian Business on Twitter at @BusinessDesk, or sign up to the daily Business Today email here.

This article titled "Regulator sorry for not capping UK consumers' energy bills sooner" was written by Adam Vaughan, for The Guardian on Wednesday 10 January 2018 01.13pm


Revealed: Cash eclipsed as Britain turns to digital payments

Britain will move beyond “peak cash” this year, according to data gathered by the Guardian that… Read more

Is this the worst leasehold block in Britain?

The freehold to a 1960s block of flats near Birmingham regarded as the worst example of leasehold… Read more

London posh-home lettings hit record high

Six- and seven-bedroom houses in Notting Hill and Primrose Hill were among a record number of… Read more

Waitrose customer left ‘horrified’ after sausage label mix-up

My partner bought what he thought were 12 Angus beef sausages from Waitrose just before Christmas… Read more

NatWest Bank tests Cora, an AI bot that will answer customer questions

NatWest is testing an artificial intelligence-powered “digital human” called Cora that will… Read more

Is this the beginning of the end for cash? Readers on the rise of digitised payments

What do barber shops, buses, street markets, shisha bars and grandchildren at Christmas all have in… Read more

Energy company promises to pay customers to use electricity

A small energy company has launched a new tariff that will potentially pay customers to use its… Read more

Play-it-safe banks ‘de-risk’ and freeze out customers

Frozen: £19,221 Barclays bank summarily closed my personal and business accounts four years ago and… Read more

'I don't use contactless': the woman whose name is on British banknotes

It is perhaps not entirely surprising to learn that the woman whose signature adorns Bank of… Read more

Freehold of 'worst leasehold abuse' block sold for £180,000

The freehold to a block of flats in Birmingham regarded as the worst example of leasehold abuse in… Read more