Art and design






Life and style








US news

World news

Philip Glass and Laurie Anderson: American Style review – avant-garde pioneers going nowhere

Philip Glass, left, cellist Rubin Kodheli and and Laurie Anderson, right, at the Royal Festival Hall, London.
Retrospective of sorts … Philip Glass, left, cellist Rubin Kodheli and and Laurie Anderson, right, at the Royal Festival Hall, London. Photograph: Tristram Kenton for the Guardian

Philip Glass and Laurie Anderson go back a long way, to the heyday of New York minimalism in the 1970s, when Glass was one of the pioneers of that new musical language, and Anderson was just starting out on her boundary-crossing career with its mixture of wryly humorous narratives and multimedia performance art. Their creative paths have crossed occasionally since, and American Style, their latest collaboration which they have been touring since last year, is a retrospective of sorts. In fact it conjures up the laid-back atmosphere of a meeting between two old friends, who get down to reminiscing and worrying over the direction their country is taking at the moment.

It’s all rather low-key (more or less always the same one, in fact, as far as the music is concerned), one-paced, and lacks any real sense of shape. Even the state of the US today seems to arouse more disappointment and sorrow than anger, and the fact that the two are sitting down in front of an audience of a couple of thousand seems almost irrelevant – it’s more a private collection of memories than a performance. Glass sticks to his piano, Anderson commutes between her trademark electric violin and a sampling keyboard, but there’s a cellist too, Rubin Kodheli, whose main role seems to be to flesh out musical textures or add swooning melodic lines, usually to counterproductive effect.

Laurie Anderson on electric violin.
Laurie Anderson on electric violin. Photograph: Tristram Kenton for the Guardian

Glass, if anything, takes the subsidiary role. He does play one of his piano studies, though even that has to be embellished by Kodheli, and provides a live, rather Randy Newman-like accompaniment to a recording of Allen Ginsberg reading his anti-war poem Wichita Vortex Sutra, and does the same to a tape of Anderson’s late husband Lou Reed. But it’s left to Anderson to give the evening what substance there is. Her strength has always been the lingering power of her words, which she cocoons in electronica; here Glass’s gently nurdling piano effortlessly merges into the ambient soundscapes that surround the anecdotes, which are sometimes charming but occasionally insistently important.

There’s always the sense, though, that the whole evening has turned out to be significantly less than the sum of its illustrious parts.

This article titled "Philip Glass and Laurie Anderson: American Style review – avant-garde pioneers going nowhere" was written by Andrew Clements, for The Guardian on Friday 19 May 2017 01.14pm


‘What’s the most strong and stable thing in your tent?’ – meet 2017's Glastonbury campers

Rebecca Webb, 24, Essex, and friends Who are you here with? All the girls – we go to a new festival… Read more

Glastonbury 2017: Sunday evening, with Ed Sheeran and Boy Better Know – as it happened

I’m now watching Barry Gibb on the iPlayer and reminiscing fondly about my favourite Glastonbury… Read more

Glastonbury 2017: 'the best one yet', declares organiser Emily Eavis

As a politically fired-up Glastonbury 2017 ends, co-organiser Emily Eavis has said: “It has to be… Read more

Glastonbury 2017 verdict: Radiohead, Foo Fighters, Lorde, Stormzy and more

Midway through the festival, the Spectator’s website published a bonkers article headlined… Read more

Twitter joke about Barry Gibb's Glastonbury 'covers' descends into farce

It was a joke so obvious that people on Twitter could not possibly take it literally – could they?… Read more

Ed Sheeran at Glastonbury 2017 review – defiantly alone and thrillingly raw

“I have to admit,” offers Ed Sheeran at the start of the weekend’s final Pyramid stage headlining… Read more

The Glastonbury 2017 barometer – strong and stable, or weak and wobbly?

Strong and stable Unfashionable genres Thundercat repping jazz fusion and Lemon Twigs bringing back… Read more

Glastonbury 2017: Sunday daytime with Chic, Barry Gibb and the Killers – as it happened

We’re still coming to terms with that onslaught of positive vibes: Barry Gibb and Chic bringing… Read more

BCMG/Knussen review – a shimmering string of musical jewels

As a conductor Oliver Knussen may be a constant and vital force in British contemporary music, but… Read more

Vince Staples: Big Fish Theory review – good vibrations and gunfire

You’ll occasionally hear seagulls on Vince Staples’s records. Raised in Compton and Long Beach, the… Read more