Art and design

Books

Culture

Environment

Fashion

Film

Life and style

Money

Music

Politics

Science

Technology

Travel

Television

US news

World news

The British empire’s role in ending slavery | Letters

The deck of an 18th-century slave ship
Africans on the deck of an 18th-century slave ship. Image: Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Whatever you think of the Treasury tweet (The Treasury’s tweet shows slavery is still misunderstood, 13 February), we do have a lot to be proud of about the moral and political campaign, started by Quakers in the 1780s, to abolish the slave trade.

It is unclear from David Olusoga’s article whether he believes that payments to slave owners actually benefited slaves and their descendants or otherwise. If there was a better course of action available, what was it? Perhaps a physical blockade of Africa to enforce the ban on British ships transporting slaves would have helped? The Royal Navy did just that in 1808, establishing the West Africa Squadron to do so.

Britain did more than abolish slavery, it took robust action against the slave traders and strongly encouraged others to do the same. I would rather defend Britain’s record than, say, that of Ethiopia, where slavery and involuntary servitude were only officially abolished in 1942, or that of Saudi Arabia, where it took another 20 years.
Paul Martin
London

• As well as the vast compensation given to slave owners, David Olusoga mentions the apprenticeship system that replaced slavery, which in 1837 Henry Sterne called “equally bad, if not worse than slavery”. Under slavery black women had fought hard for some basic rights, like a less harsh workload during pregnancy, breastfeeding time, the provision of limited childcare, and food and clothing for their children. Intended to soften the blow for slave owners, under the apprenticeship system, these rights were withdrawn. Emancipation actually led to the deterioration of black women’s lives.
Rosie Turner
Leamington Spa

• One point to add to David Olusoga’s article on the “end” of slavery in the British empire: it didn’t really end. Slavery was replaced by a system of indentured labour in the many British colonies where plantations were the main income generators.

People from India were shipped thousands of miles to work for minimal wages for a fixed number of years with limited rights. This system persisted until 1917. No mention was made of this in the history I learned in school. I wonder if it is included now?
Roger Downie
Glasgow

• David Olusoga rightly criticises the Abolition of Slavery Act of 1833 for its obscene generosity of £20m granted as compensation to slave owners “for the loss of their human property”. It did not free all slaves in the empire as the countless school textbooks insist, because well into the 20th century slavery was still in existence in Sierra Leone, Gambia, Burma, Hong Kong and northern Nigeria – a fact that Britain confessed to the League of Nations in 1924.

Glorifying Britain’s role in the past is typical of the manipulation of our history which has been going on over centuries. The Abolition Act must be seen alongside other such mythologised “facts” as the “fair governance” of our colonies and “Britain alone” in 1940. It’s a shame that the all too numerous “factoids” in the history books cannot be deleted as easily as the Treasury’s tweet!
Bernie Evans
Liverpool

• Kenan Malik (Let’s put an end to the delusion that Britain abolished slavery, theguardian.com, 11 February) has selectively blamed the British for their role in the 17th-century slave trade. Granted, British and other European “businessmen” did internationalise the slave trade, but the practice was invented by African chiefs who had been capturing and selling slaves within the continent and to the Middle East for centuries before the transatlantic trade. Today, African leaders are still at it, driving, through corruption and mismanagement, hundreds of thousands of Africans to seek a better life in Europe. Many have ended up in the Libyan slave markets.
Sam Akaki
Executive director, African Solutions to African Migration

• Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com

• Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters

This article titled "The British empire’s role in ending slavery" was written by Letters, for The Guardian on Wednesday 14 February 2018 05.36pm

World news

European Union MPs call on Xi Jinping to release Gui Minhai

Dozens of EU politicians have written to the Chinese president, Xi Jinping, demanding the immediate… Read more

Oxfam deserves criticism, but this is a gift for the anti-aid ideologues | Letters

Afua Hirsch (A white saviour mentality lies behind the Oxfam scandal, 21 February) is certainly… Read more

New Russian stealth fighter spotted in Syria

Moscow appears to have deployed an advanced new stealth fighter to its airbase in Syria, reports in… Read more

Paris: legal challenge to car-free promenade by Seine

When pedestrians reclaimed a stretch of once traffic-clogged dual carriageway on Paris’s right bank… Read more

Not who but how: EU split over choosing Juncker successor

It has been the talk of Brussels coffee bars for weeks, and now European leaders are gathering for… Read more

Medical crisis in east Ghouta as hospitals 'systematically targeted'

The medical system in eastern Ghouta is near collapse, medics and doctors say, after nearly a week… Read more

Indian state offers free breast implants to the poor

A south Indian state has become possibly the first in the world to offer publicly-funded breast… Read more

Friday briefing: Flake news! Russia spawns 'beast from the east'

Top story: Get ready for -8C as snowy weather hits Hello, I’m Warren Murray and this is what we’re… Read more

Justin Trudeau's India visit overshadowed by invitation to attempted murderer

Justin Trudeau’s state visit to India has been overshadowed by revelations that a businessman… Read more

Spanish artist decries censorship after work dropped from art fair

The Spanish artist at the centre of a censorship row has attacked the lack of freedom of expression… Read more